ASKING QUESTIONS, EXPLORING OPTIONS, CHANGING THE IMPACT OF PUBLIC EDUCATION.

School House

Bilingualism.

Bilingualism

Did you know that almost every School District in the state of Texas offers a Dual Language program?

A Dual Language Program main goal is to integrate English Language Learners and English-speaking students for instruction in two languages, generally English and Spanish.

Different from transitional bilingual programs, where the aim is to transition students out of their native language, dual language helps students to maintain their primary language while a second language is added.

The Dual Language Program is also known as “two-way immersion”, “two-way bilingual”, “bilingual immersion”, and “dual-language immersion”. This program is part of the school district’s bilingual curriculum. Unfortunately, dual language is only available to a few select students. Some schools take applications of those who are interested in the dual language program and at times are selected through a lottery.

There is big advantage to speaking more than one language. Schools in Sweden begin at elementary school with English and by the time they reach 8th grade, they can speak English, French, Spanish, and German. They are now also adding Chinese to their curriculum in addition to their native Swedish.

What does the brain research tell us about bilingualism or being multilingual?

Brain has the amazing capability of different language representations. Several studies suggest that learning second or third languages is easier for young children, and the earlier you start the better. Different neurophysiologic and neuroimaging studies have shown evidence of overlapping brain areas when two languages are acquired before the age of 7. The Bilingual brain cerebral representations of languages seem to change after 7, especially after puberty.

People have several misconceptions on bilingualism. Bilingual parents have serious concerns if they should expose their child to two languages from birth. They also have great concerns that their child will fall behind monolingual children, however research shows that babies of bilingual parents can tell the difference from birth.

I see it in my classroom with 4 and 5 year olds. Children of bilingual parents can switch between English and Spanish without a problem. They are totally aware of what sounds or signs are in the language and what sounds are not. Whenever a bilingual student is tested for English proficiency and may not know the English word for red, he will automatically use the characteristics of the English pronunciation on to the Spanish word rojo (ryoh-Hoh).

Ellen Bialystok, a cognitive neuroscientist, who has spent almost 40 years learning how bilingualism works, explained the following. “There’s a system in your brain, the executive control system. It’s a general manager. Its job is to keep you focused on what is relevant, while ignoring distractions. It’s what makes it possible for you to hold two different things in your mind at one time and switch between them.”

This is also her response to the all so common question, if a child should be exposed to two languages or not. “There are two major reasons people should pass their heritage language onto children. First, it connects children to their ancestors. The second is my research: Bilingualism is good for you. It makes brains stronger. It is brain exercise.”

In explaining how the brain works and the difference between acquiring a language at an early age versus in High School, I will use Paradis research model on Bilingualism who wrote that there is a distinction between implicit and explicit knowledge of language.

Paradis uses the expression -implicit computational procedure- to refer to subconscious and internalized set of rules that allows a speaker to give a grammatical structure to strings of words in a way compatible with how other native speakers do so.  He theorizes that this is subserved by the procedural memory in an automatic and effortless way.

Paradis theorizes that –explicit knowledge- is subserved by declarative memory. Adult second language learners rely on their declarative memory. This is because “Paradis argues that it is the ability to incorporate knowledge into procedural memory that atrophies in adults.” He says adults do this to compensate from the loss of procedural memory. He explains that this is the reason why the result of a second language in adulthood tends to be less fluent manner of speaking and more hesitant. This explains why it is so hard for adult immigrants to learn a new language and why their children have the ability to learn both languages faster and easier if they stay exposed to both languages throughout their lifetime.

I personally find this part of his article extremely poignant on the importance of teaching a second language in our Public Schools at a younger age whether it is Spanish or any other language for that matter. By the time they get to High School students linguistic knowledge is no longer automatic and effortless as he puts it. By now the students will be using their declarative memory. His research helps support that of others in the importance of starting a second language in the early years.

I would love to hear your opinion on this. Would you like to see other languages taught to your child?

Do you believe that Public School should integrate other languages into their curriculum?



11 Responses

  1. Jackie says:

    I truly relate to this article. I grew up in Mexico city and went to a bilingual school since preK and most of my friends from school knew both languages Spanish an English very well. I think that the younger they are the easier it is for children to learn different languages. Unfortunately my niece and nephews never took the opportunity to learn both languages. Now they are in High School and they are having difficulties learning it. Children are like sponges ready to absorb as much as they can.

    • Carmen says:

      Thanks Jacky! That is the point I wanted to make. If children are taught languages earlier it will be easier for them to learn. By the time they get to high school, they can still learn them but the process will be different and much more elaborate.
      Thanks for sharing your experience.

  2. Jenny :-) says:

    Absolutely! I would love for our children to be taught other languages along side English in a regular classroom setting! Simply exposing them to the different sounds, tones, pronunciation, etc. at an early age will make a world of difference and when they grow up, if they want to learn another language, it will be much easier to develop. It’s not a hard case to make for the public school system, the main challenge will be the funding for such programs as I imagine those programs can be costly.
    Great article!

    • Carmen says:

      You are so right Jenny. It is all about funding. I just read that Arizona got funding for a three-year federal Foreign Language Assistance Program grant worth $650,000. I read in the article that it has paid for two full-time and one part-time Mandarin teacher for Diamond Canyon and Gavilan Peak elementary schools in Anthem. It is happening right now as we speak. They have actually launched a program for students in younger grades, kindergarten to sixth. Mesa Public Schools was one of the districts at the forefront of offering Mandarin Chinese. The district has now added Chinese language to five of their schools schools: Dobson High, Westwood High, Hendrix Junior High, Rhodes Junior High and Mesa Academy, according to their Assistant Superintendent Suzan DePrez. Picture this now, students also can take Chinese through their online Mesa Distance Learning Program. It just make sense when U.S. has trade and very important foreign ties with China. Until then, 再见 (zĂ ijiĂ n) “Good Bye” in Chinese. Thanks for your comment.

  3. I really like how you’ve explained the difference between bilingual and dual language. How fortunate students are to be offered a dual language program in Texas. It seems as if better educated and affulent parents wanting to enroll their students in this type of program. It’s almost as if it is a status symbol of an intelligent child.
    The benefits of being bilingual are immense in our global society. I grew up in the mid-west, at a time when there were no dual language or ESL programs. I saw learning Spanish as a way to connect with the world, instead of staying in a secluded world. I believe more people will come to view bilingualism as necessary rather than an asset.

    • Carmen says:

      I love the way you describe it! “Learning Spanish as a way to connect to the world” Because when one learns a language one indirectly learns about the similarities and the differences that exist among two worlds that coexist side by side. As the world becomes more global there will be more demand for younger generations to communicate with those who are non-English speakers if we wish to succeed in the world market. Thanks for sharing.

  4. jean j says:

    It seems as though a program teaching children a second language at an early age is only avalable to certain students in certain areas,
    I do wish we could open up a program like this for all students in all areas.
    At an early age, they are so receptive to picking up another language; whereas the older they get, it just seems more difficult and they have to struggle more in learning the language. It just gets harder for them to learn another language and they get frustrated and disappointed, and begin to feel that learning another language is just too difficult.
    They seem to begin to lose their motivation to learn another language.
    I really wish our very young students were not limited in learning a foreign language and more possibilities would open up for them.

    • Carmen says:

      You are so right Jean the younger the better, but even if you are older you should also give it a try. Languages help keep the brain in shape. Then again I find languages fun. Thanks for you comment!

  5. I agree with your view on the Dual Language benefits and I wish that it was available to a greater group of students. There is not DL in all school districts, but I wish that they did.

    Great Job!

    • carmen says:

      Thanks Gloria for your comment.
      I also wish all districts would offer DL. Then again I would love to see the option of learning a second and third language part of the school regular curriculum. Thanks for your comment!

  6. The very next time I read a blog, I hope that it does not disappoint me as much as this particular one. After all, Yes, it was my choice to read, however I genuinely believed you would have something useful to say. All I hear is a bunch of complaining about something you can fix if you weren’t too busy seeking attention. nonprescription colored contacts http://8tracks.com/ferry0crocus

Leave a Reply